4 - The Path to Diatoma in Candolle's Key

In the first edition of Flore françoise Lamarck had pioneered the use of dichotomous keys as aides to identification, and they were continued in subsequent editions. While the characters employed in a key need not necessarily be those used to construct a classification or diagnose a genus, they often are and are by no means necessarily excluded from it. It is at least instructive to look at how Diatoma falls out of Candolle's key to the algae in Flore.


Figure 9 (above). From Lamarck & Candolle, Flore française, ed. 3,
vol. 1 (1805). Alternate images: Hydrodictyon (Russ Kleinman, http://www.wnmu.edu/academic/nspages/gilaflora/hydrodictyon
_sp.html), Vaucheria (Y. Tsukii,http://protist.i.hosei.ac.jp/pdb/
Images/Heterokontophyta/Vaucheria/sp_3.html), Batrachospermum (T. Tsukii, http://protist.i.hosei.ac.jp/
pdb/
Images/Others/Rhodophyta/Batrachospermum/sp_06.html).

Passing down the key to the algae (Figure 9) one leaves behind filaments anatamosed as a net (Hydrodictyon, 990), filaments continuous and not partitioned (Vaucheria, 991), covered with a gelatinous coating (Batrachospermum, 993), and living in fresh water (994), until a final pair (995) of marine plants is reached: Diatoma and Ceramium (Figures 10 & 11).

Diatoma had segments (articles) longer than wide, the plants very often cut crosswise by articulations;
Ceramium
's segments were wider than long and not at all disposed to being cut transversely.

The congruence of the descriptions in the key of the filaments as cut crosswise, the generic description covering both species emphasizing segments which separate from one another except at their corners, and the explicit reference to the Roth figure in which the form is manifestly that of an incised filament reinforces the conclusion that this cleavage of the filament was the focus of the generic diagnosis and the name. Had his specimens been freshwater, one can easily imagine Candolle as having viewed them as cloven confervas.



Figure 10. A filament of Rhabdonema arcuatum showing the
same notched appearance as would be expected in Candolle's
Diatoma. Image: StarCentral. http://starcentral.mbl.edu/msr/
rawdata/viewable/rhabdonema_arcuatum_1320674074_g_543w.jpg. Accessed 2 December 2012.


Figure 11. Ceramium echionotum, showing no notches between the segments (cells). Image: AlgaeBase, Spanish Point, County Clare, Ireland, 28 Aug 2010. M.D. Guiry. © Michael Guiry (mike.guiry@nuigalway.ie).

<-- 3 - Candolle's Diatoma -

Creative Commons License
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.